Why I do not want to give a home one overall score
Let’s explore this page together
A property score embeds someone else’s priorities. I would rather make the differences and essential conditions visible to the buyer on NovAsia.
This article reflects the named expert’s practical perspective. See NovAsia’s editorial policy for how material is prepared and reviewed.
A single property score quietly answers a question the buyer may never have been asked: how much should each feature matter? Extra space, an easier journey and a view receive weights, and the final number presents those choices as though they belong to the home itself.
For NovAsia, an 8.7 rating leaves the central question unanswered: whose life did we use to calculate it?
Some conditions should not cancel each other out
Imagine two properties, one more spacious and the other nearer the buyer's routine. Either can be a reasonable choice. A move-in deadline is different: if the home cannot meet it, a pool or an attractive kitchen may not compensate at all.
Unknown information creates an even sharper problem. A missing document can become a small numerical penalty, then be offset by a strong view. The resulting score looks acceptable although the buyer might refuse to discuss payment until that document is available. The formula has made a consequential choice on their behalf.
Publishing the weights makes that decision visible. The weights still belong to whoever designed the formula. A useful comparison starts by finding out which requirements the buyer can trade and which they cannot.
Leave room for a different choice
I want a comparison to show the actual differences: more usable space here, a more convenient verified route there, an unanswered payment condition in the third column. Measurements can remain numbers without being combined into a verdict about suitability and reliability.
The buyer should also be able to change a requirement and understand why the shortlist changes. A guest room may cease to be essential; a working corner might suffice. Returning an option to the comparison is more useful than defending a score assigned before that change.
The rating earns its place only if it adds something to the comparison. When the buyer still has to reopen every underlying fact and reconsider their priorities, the extra decimal has made the journey longer.
A score can be a tool without becoming a verdict
I am not against scoring as such. A number can be useful when it answers one narrow, visible question. A list might rank homes by verified travel time to a chosen address, or show which layouts provide the most usable area within a fixed budget. In those cases the metric is doing a defined job. It is not pretending to summarise the home, the transaction and the buyer's priorities at once.
The difficulty begins when unlike things are compressed into the same scale. Price, floor area and distance are measurements. Layout quality depends on how someone intends to live. Confidence in a completion date depends on evidence. An unconfirmed compulsory charge is not simply a weak feature that can be cancelled out by a better view. Once all of those are turned into points, precise arithmetic can give an impression of precision that the underlying judgement does not deserve.
I find it more useful to separate non-negotiable conditions from preferences. A maximum budget, a required move-in date or a legal condition may remove an option entirely. A higher floor, a larger balcony or extra space beyond the minimum may be tradeable. When those categories remain visible, the buyer can see why a home left the shortlist and what would need to change for it to return. “No longer meets the move-in date” is more informative than a score falling from 8.7 to 7.9.
Explainability matters as well. If the platform cannot describe a ranking in ordinary language without referring to an opaque formula, the ranking is carrying too much authority. “This home ranks lower because it misses your stated deadline” is understandable and contestable. The buyer can change the deadline and watch the list respond. A composite number encourages the opposite behaviour: people start debating the number instead of the conditions underneath it.
Personalisation does not solve the problem automatically. A model can ask the buyer for weights, but those weights can still become false precision. Someone may say that commute matters twice as much as a balcony and then discover, after seeing two real homes, that the trade-off feels different. A useful system should let the requirement change without treating the earlier answer as a mistake.
The role of calculation, in my view, is to expose the structure of a choice. It can organise a large catalogue and highlight meaningful differences. It should not turn an unresolved preference or an unanswered document question into a decimal that looks final. The best comparison leaves the buyer with a clearer decision, not with a more impressive number.